top of page

"The Unthinkable Daughter Review" : Netflix offers up another true doc

3 days ago
2 min read

Just as Lifetime once had viewers in a chokehold with its women-in-jeopardy movies, Netflix has found its bread and butter in true-crime documentaries. Whether the subject is a notorious killer or a case that slipped under the radar, the streaming giant knows there’s an audience ready to tune in. Its latest offering, The Unthinkable Daughter, takes viewers to Brazil for the disturbing story of Suzane von Richthofen.


In 2002, Suzane’s parents, Manfred and Marísia von Richthofen, were brutally murdered inside their São Paulo home. The shocking twist? Their teenage daughter helped orchestrate the crime alongside her boyfriend and his brother, who carried out the killings. What was supposed to resemble a robbery quickly unraveled, eventually leading to convictions for all three.


Now, more than two decades later, directors Lygia M. Barbosa and Paulo Gambale Maká give Suzane a chance to discuss her past and the life she’s trying to build after her release from prison.


Admittedly, I wasn’t familiar with the case beforehand, so the documentary had my attention early. There’s something inherently unsettling about a young woman helping arrange the murders of the very people who raised her. However, once the circumstances are established, I began wondering what else the filmmakers intended to reveal.


The documentary’s biggest selling point is Suzane herself, speaking publicly after years away from the spotlight. Unfortunately, access doesn’t automatically translate into insight. While she discusses her involvement and attempts to explain her decisions, I never felt the film successfully bridged the gap between acknowledging responsibility and demonstrating genuine remorse.


And therein lies my biggest issue. True crime documentaries don’t necessarily need shocking revelations to justify their existence. Sometimes a thoughtful examination of the people involved is enough.


However, “The Unthinkable Daughter” seems more interested in presenting Suzane’s perspective than consistently challenging it. The more compelling material arrives when the conversation shifts toward rehabilitation. Can someone responsible for such a horrific crime genuinely change? And after serving years behind bars, what does society owe that individual?


Those are fascinating questions, particularly when the crime involves one’s own family. Unfortunately, the filmmakers only scratch the surface before moving along.


To their credit, the archival material and interviews provide enough context for viewers unfamiliar with the case. The documentary also avoids turning the murders into an elaborate mystery when the basic facts are already established.


Still, I wanted more examination and less explanation. Suzane’s willingness to appear on camera may be noteworthy, but that alone doesn’t make her reflections particularly revealing.


Ultimately, “The Unthinkable Daughter” is an unsettling introduction to a notorious Brazilian crime, even if its examination of accountability falls short. Netflix has delivered another watchable true-crime documentary, but this is one case where the unanswered questions are far more interesting than the answers provided.


Final Grade : C+


"The Unthinkable Daughter" is streaming on Netflix now.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

© 2026 Reviews & Dunn. All rights reserved.

bottom of page