“The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping Review” — Haymitch Deserves Better

Director Francis Lawrence, who helmed last year’s highly enjoyable film The Long Walk, returns to Panem with Lionsgate’s “The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping”. The screenplay was adapted by Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie from Suzanne Collins’s novel of the same name.
I was particularly curious to see how Haymitch Abernathy managed to win his Games. Woody Harrelson portrayed him as a man with a lifetime of stories he’d prefer to keep buried. After watching this latest film, I found myself wanting to revisit Catching Fire.
The 50th Hunger Games provides the Capitol with an opportunity to double the number of tributes. Sixteen-year-old Haymitch (played by Joseph Zada) enters the arena alongside fellow District 12 tribute Maysilee Donner (Mckenna Grace). The two form an unlikely alliance, and Haymitch begins to see a chance to challenge President Snow (Ralph Fiennes) from within the Games.
However, I never fully connected with Zada in the role. I could accept his portrayal of Haymitch as a young man who still believes he has a future, but I struggled to believe him as he began to fight back. When the alliance with Maysilee gives him someone else to care about in the arena,
I wanted to see him grapple with the potential consequences of his choices. While I understood why he would take the risk, Zada’s performance rarely conveyed the weight of that decision. In contrast, Grace provided more reasons to care about whether the two of them would survive their next encounter.
Cinematographer Joe Willems made good use of daylight to stage much of the arena action. This allowed viewers to follow the action clearly and see what the Capitol intended them to witness. The clearer the violence became, the more disturbing it felt to watch children suffer, packaged as entertaining television. Lawrence still knows how to make the Games unsettling, even with the arena’s familiar mechanics.
The reliance on nostalgia is where the film begins to feel like a cash grab. I can support the casting of Jesse Plemons as a young Plutarch and Elle Fanning as Effie. Still, every time the movie pauses to introduce another familiar face, it distracts from the kids whose futures are truly uncertain. After a while, it felt like the film was more interested in showing who used to be who than in focusing on the story at hand—an unfortunate drawback for a prequel.
I entered the theater wanting to understand what it cost Haymitch to survive, but I left thinking about how effectively Harrelson conveyed that cost with just a single look. This movie used the entire arena to make me feel the stakes.
Final Grade: C
"The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping” is in theaters now.


