"Caught Stealing" is another showcase for Austin Butler

Director Darren Aronofsky brings his unique cinematic vision to an adaptation of Charlie Huston’s 2004 novel “Caught Stealing,” produced by Columbia Pictures. Huston also pens the film’s screenplay.

There’s a familiar American sadness at the center of “*Caught Stealing,” which explores the heartbreak of a life that peaked too early. Hank Thompson, a former high school baseball prodigy, can no longer play and grapples with the quiet loss that shapes his existence.

Austin Butler delivers a grounded performance as Hank, who, despite not being miserable, understands the gap between his dreams and reality. He bartends at a New York dive, enjoys his girlfriend’s affection, and finds joy in watching his favorite team. His choice to avoid asking for more gives the film emotional weight as the story shifts dramatically.

The inciting incident occurs when Hank’s punk-rock neighbor, Russ (Matt Smith), asks him to watch his cat. This seemingly simple favor thrusts Hank into a dangerous situation, attracting criminals who believe he has something they need, though he remains unaware of what it is.

The film isn’t a glamorous crime thriller; it’s messy and driven by panic. The gangsters pursuing Hank feel more realistic than cinematic stereotypes, and each encounter escalates his peril. Hank scrambles not to win, but to survive and understand what’s happening.

Zoë Kravitz serves as the emotional heart of the film, portraying a girlfriend who is aware of the changing dynamics and adds tension to Hank’s journey. Regina King also provides solid support as a detective looking to take Hank down.

“Caught Stealing” excels in its empathy for a man unprepared for chaos, demonstrating that he survives through instinct and resilience. The title reflects both stolen money and a life that went off course early on. Ultimately, the film is about reclaiming agency and illustrates that survival can be an act of defiance in the face of unexpected challenges.

Final Grade: B+

“Caught Stealing” is available digitally and on Netflix.